Good judgment comes from experience and experience comes from bad judgment, or so goes the adage.
Mistakes and misadventures might not be fun at the time, but they can teach us valuable lessons. Reflecting on my own mistakes in the backcountry – and the following three are certainly not the extent of my errors – I realise that each has had a ripple effect on my time in the outdoors, helping improve preparation, decision-making and ability for self-reliance. Although learning from others’ mistakes might not be as impactful as learning from one’s own, I hope readers find some take-outs in mine.
You are not smarter than your compass
We left Maungahuka Hut early, headed for the Holdsworth Road end and planning to complete a weekend crossing of the central Tararua Range. The weather hadn’t been great, but we were fit, confident and comfortable enough. After a long descent off Aokaparangi to Mid Waiohine Hut, we ate lunch before launching upwards through the bush towards the summit of Mt Holdsworth.
At the summit trig the cloud was so thick we couldn’t see more than a few metres. We paused for a moment, confident we knew the direction of Powell Hut. But we checked anyway, just to be sure. Unwaveringly, the compass needle said we should walk in the opposite direction to what we thought.
We scratched our heads, and moved away from the trig in case it was causing interference. Still the same. It must be broken, we decided. Connan was in the hills every available weekend. I’d climbed Aoraki/Mt Cook the previous summer. We were the experts. So off we walked into the cloud, following our infallible internal compasses.
We walked for longer than expected before we finally spotted a hut. But our sense of satisfaction was short-lived. It was not Powell, but Jumbo. The wrong hut, in the wrong direction entirely. No matter, we thought. A track from there led to the same road end. We’d just be walking a bit longer.
But then, as the hut neared, it dawned on us that we had been very lucky to have arrived there. Instead of walking in a south easterly direction, we’d walked north, then unwittingly drifted east, to descend to Jumbo Hut. If we’d thought we were walking in the right direction for Powell, our path should have continued north-east, deeper into the range. But if we’d been paying any attention to our navigation at all, we should have noticed the 140m climb onto Jumbo. No such ascent exists when descending to Powell Hut from Mt Holdsworth.

